This
opinion and others linked here are contributed by a group
of Maldivians who call themselves the Society
for the Promotion of Human Rights in Maldives.This
web site and its editor do not have any input into these
opinions or the Society for the Promotion of Human Rights
in Maldives, other than providing a forum, as required
by Law. This opinion is published within the context of
Section 14 of the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990.We
do not publish material from those who do not provide sufficient
personal information to enable us to establish their identity.
|
Maldives is a place visited by many tourists. All tourist brochures
describe the country as paradise, a beautiful place where worries
are not known and which is in a constant state of bliss.
There are many people in Maldives who like to believe in the
tourist-brochure view of their country. They like to think that
Maldives is a peaceful and quiet archipelago, like some small
country in the Pacific or the Caribbean.
United States Department of
State
Bureau of
Democracy, Human Rights, and Labor
International
Religious Freedom Report 2004
"President
Maumoon Abdul Gayoom repeatedly has stated that no religion
other than Islam should be allowed in the country, and the
Home Affairs Ministry announced special programs to safeguard
and strengthen religious unity. The Government has established
a Supreme Council of Islamic Affairs to provide guidance
on religious matters." |
But nothing could be farther from the truth. The fact is that
the Maldives is no easy-going tropical island country, for it
is at the top of the list of states where religious persecution
is harshest and most relentless.
Among the roughly 180 countries of the world, the Maldives is
placed in the sixth position, concerning intolerance against and
harassment of minorities.
World Watch List ranking of countries according to index of religious
persecution (first 7)
Note that none of the countries mentioned in that list is an
attractive destination for tourists. They are bleak countries,
some of them like Laos and Vietnam scarred by war, or religious
or communist tyrannies, like North Korea, Saudi Arabia and Iran,
which no one in his sane mind would like to visit for a holiday.
Lastly, note that Somalia, which comes in the list AFTER the Maldives,
is the most lawless country in the world, but even there the harassment
of religious minorities is a notch less bad than in Maldives.
This should be alarming enough, but Maldivians tend to think
that claiming that their country is 100% Muslim is a harmless
statement and, instead of being ashamed, the government actually
wants its citizens to be proud of it. But the fact is that it
is a gross violation of human rights for many Maldivians who secretly
would wish to have the right not to be religious.
One reaps what one sows, so when
instead of human rights, and mutual respect and affection, Islamic
religious fanaticism is actively promoted by the state, as well
as by the so-called 'democratic' opposition, it is very unlikely
that a peaceful and tolerant new generation will emerge in the
MaldivesThe government in Malé repeatedly slanders
and vilifies progressive and open-minded Maldivians. It claims
that Maldives is a 100% Muslim country in order to sideline possible
reform movements, stressing that belonging to anything else but
the Muslim ideology would be against Maldivian tradition. But
this is a fallacy, for Maldive society has gone through deep changes
in the last three decades and the traditional Maldivian mellow
Muslim society is in practice no longer existing.
Many years ago the Maldive Islands were a very isolated country
and there was almost no influence from abroad. Then, around 1970,
President Ibrahim Nasir opened up the borders of the country and
welcomed tourists and foreign investment. Therefore, beginning
about thirty years ago, all Maldivians have been heavily influenced
by the modern societies from overseas. For the first time in this
island nation's history, many Maldivians entered into contact
with tourists, visiting businessmen and teachers, while many other
traveled abroad as sailors and students.
But during the past two decades, after Gayoom came to power,
the Maldive society underwent a polarization. For the first time
in history, a significant number of young Maldivians went to Arab
schools and let themselves be indoctrinated against modernism
and progress. Their new brand of Islam was no longer the traditional
laid-back Maldive form of Islam, but a new intransigent, militant
Islam, hitherto unknown in Maldives. These new hard-line elements
destroyed that ancient traditional Maldivian Islam and set out
to influence the whole Maldivian society.
Even so, these hard-liners are still a minority in the Maldivian
society and the truth is that these present-day Islamic militants
are a recent development, not representing Maldivian tradition
in any way. And since the clock cannot be set back because the
traditional Maldivian way of life has disappeared, most Maldivians,
given the choice, prefer the influences of modern civilized societies
over the influence of Arab intolerant ideas. Therefore many Maldivians
would like to live in a modern secular state, but they are too
afraid or too intimidated to come out into the open and say so.
These open-minded and progressive Maldivians are dismissed as
non-existent by the government because they are too scared to
speak out or because they have been persecuted and tortured into
submission. These Maldivians have not dared to come to the surface
and their number is as yet unknown because President Gayoom is
not doing anything to restrain Muslim extremism. And radical elements
within the Maldivian society would threaten and endanger the lives
of those Maldivians who would dare to speak openly for tolerance.
The reason is that Islam cannot tolerate criticism, and it is
unable by its very nature to be fair and democratic. In these
conditions, lacking the necessary protection and encouragement,
open-minded Maldivian minority groups will be continually terrorized
into silence and secrecy.
The
MDP draft
manifesto states as one of its goals,
to "facilitate the progressive protection and promotion
of the Islamic faith that will strengthen the moral fabric
of the society and create civility amongst
the peoples"
The reference to "peoples" makes one wonder if
MDP has an agenda beyond the borders of the Maldives.
The MDP (Maldivian Democratic Party) is the only significant
opposition movement in the Maldives. It claims to have the
moral support of the European Union. |
The present Government's policies, if anything, are encouraging
the Islamic radical groups within the Maldives. Instead of empowering
liberal, tolerant and democratic forces within the Maldives, Gayoom
has co-opted the religious hard-liners. Since he fears and respects
them, he keeps relying on them to counter civilian opposition.
By raising the ghost of Christianity, Gayoom is depriving the
very few Maldivians who are democratic and tolerant-minded of
an even playing field. In these conditions, not even the so-called
'democratic' opposition groups have dared to confront the lack
of foundational human rights for the Maldives.
The Maldivian truly democratic forces are still hiding. They are
weak and lacking in conviction, so they cannot develop in the
harsh pro-Islamic environment created by Gayoom Instead, their
very weakness makes them a soft and easy target for his dictatorial
policies.
The Maldive civil courts
that enforce Islamic law still sentence women who give birth
as a result of rape to being flogged in public. The above
photograph shows a woman in Iran who was subjected to this
barbaric, inhuman and degrading punishment. While tourists
bask on Maldive beaches, it is possible that some unfortunate
rape-victim is being scarred for life by ruthless mullahs
somewhere across the serene waters. |
The situation is bleak because so far there is no political force
in the Maldives that strives openly for the establishment of a
secular state. The present government is active in promoting hatred
against everything "Christian", making it anathema to
Maldivianness.
Thus the present government, as well as the government that is
likely to rule the Maldives in the immediate future, are both
incompetent to rule a country which is being visited by European
tourists, because these are perceived as "Christians"
by the Islamic hard-liners. Pandering to Islamic religious extremism
from one side while welcoming non-Muslim tourists from the other
could be building up forces of potentially disastrous consequences
that the Maldivian state will be unable to control in the future.
It is a matter of serious concern that the double-faced and short-sighted
policies of Maldivian politicians, both in the government as well
as in the opposition, could be unleashing hatred and violence
among the Maldivian youth in the future.
This potential menace could easily be directed at European tourists
visiting the Maldives. But so far tourists visiting the Maldives
are unaware that such close-mindedness, intolerance and hatred
are being built up against them by the people ruling the society
that is supposed to welcome them.
During his last tour to India at the beginning of April 2005
Gayoom lectured Maldivian students in Delhi, Chennai and Trivandrum.
It is worth noting that the main line of his speeches was directed
against open-mindedness and tolerance. Gayoom argued that Maldivians
studying abroad should not deviate at all from the strict Islamic
policies set by the Maldivian government and that they should
strive hard to avoid the influence of new ideas, including liberalism,
tolerance and outspokenness.
One reaps what one sows, so when instead of human rights, and
mutual respect and affection, Islamic religious fanaticism is
actively promoted by the state, as well as by the so-called 'democratic'
opposition, it is very unlikely that a peaceful and tolerant new
generation will emerge in the Maldives.